Debunking in a world of tribes

F. Zollo, A. Bessi, M. Vicario, G. Caldarelli, L. Shekhtman, S. Havlin, W. Quattrociocchi

PLOS ONE 10, 1371 (2017)

#socialnetworks#echochambers#statistics

LQ placeholderWhen people operate in echo chambers, they focus on information adhering to their system
of beliefs. Debunking them is harder than it seems

When people operate in echo chambers, they focus on information adhering to their system of beliefs. Debunking them is harder than it seems

Social media aggregate people around common interests eliciting collective framing of narratives and worldviews. However, in such a disintermediated environment misinformation is pervasive and attempts to debunk are often undertaken to contrast this trend. In this work, we examine the effectiveness of debunking on Facebook through a quantitative analysis of 54 million users over a time span of five years (Jan 2010, Dec 2014). In particular, we compare how users usually consuming proven (scientific) and unsubstantiated (conspiracy-like) information on Facebook US interact with specific debunking posts. Our findings confirm the existence of echo chambers where users interact primarily with either conspiracy-like or scientific pages. However, both groups interact similarly with the information within their echo chamber. Then, we measure how users from both echo chambers interacted with 50,220 debunking posts accounting for both users consumption patterns and the sentiment expressed in their comments. Sentiment analysis reveals a dominant negativity in the comments to debunking posts. Furthermore, such posts remain mainly confined to the scientific echo chamber. Only few conspiracy users engage with corrections and their liking and commenting rates on conspiracy posts increases after the interaction.

Download the PDF

LQ placeholder

What was fake on the Internet this week: Why do we even bother, honestly?

Debunking in a world of tribes

Washington Post, 2015-10-30

LQ placeholder

Smentire le bufale è inutile?

Debunking in a world of tribes

Il Post, 2015-10-30

LQ placeholder

„Fake News“ an User-Interaktionen erkennen

Debunking in a world of tribes

Science ORF, 2017-12-07

LQ placeholder

La tribù fa notizia

Debunking in a world of tribes

Nòva, 2017-09-24

LQ placeholder

Curiosity is key in post-truth era

Debunking in a world of tribes

Winnipeg Free Press, 2017-09-21

LQ placeholder

Vérification des faits: cibler les groupes moins polarisés

Debunking in a world of tribes

Pieuvre, 2017-09-20

LQ placeholder

Ignorance feeds curiosity. Curiosity cures ignorance.

Debunking in a world of tribes

Gulf News, 2017-09-19

LQ placeholder

Is curiosity a casualty of the post-truth era?

Debunking in a world of tribes

The Japan Times, 2017-09-16

LQ placeholder

Come parlare a chi si oppone ai vaccini?

Debunking in a world of tribes

Wired, 2017-09-15

LQ placeholder

Curiosity is the cure for ignorance in our post-truth era

Debunking in a world of tribes

The Canberra Times, 2017-09-13

LQ placeholder

Curiosity is the cure for ignorance in our post-truth era

Debunking in a world of tribes

WA Today, 2017-09-13

LQ placeholder

Curiosity is the cure for ignorance in our post-truth era

Debunking in a world of tribes

The Age, 2017-09-13

LQ placeholder

Ignorance Feeds Curiosity. Curiosity Cures Ignorance.

Debunking in a world of tribes

Bloomberg Business, 2017-09-12

LQ placeholder

Misinformation on Facebook: contrasting false theories does not benefit to science

Debunking in a world of tribes

Alpha Galileo, 2017-07-25

LQ placeholder

Scale of non-locality for a system of n particles

S. Talaganis, I. Teimouri

Sub. to Physical Review D

LQ placeholder

How much can we influence the rate of innovation?

T. Fink, M. Reeves

Science Advances

LQ placeholder

The statistical physics of real-world networks

G. Cimini, T. Squartini, F. Saracco, D. Garlaschelli, A. Gabrielli, G. Caldarelli

Nature Reviews Physics

LQ placeholder

On defining the Hamiltonian beyond quantum theory

D. Branford, O. Dahlsten, A. Garner

Foundations of Physics

LQ placeholder

Reconstructing grain-shape statistics from electron back-scatter diffraction microscopy

R. Farr, Z. Vukmanovic, M. Holness, E. Griffiths

Physical Review Materials

LQ placeholder

Tackling information asymmetry in networks: a new entropy-based ranking index

P. Barucca, G. Caldarelli, T. Squartini

Journal of Statistical Physics

LQ placeholder

Eigenvalues of subgraphs of the cube

B. Bollobás, J. Lee, S. Letzter

European Journal of Combinatorics

LQ placeholder

Maximum one-shot dissipated work from Rényi divergences

N. Halpern, A. Garner, O. Dahlsten, V. Vedral

Physical Review E

LQ placeholder

A holistic approach for collaborative workload execution in volunteer clouds

S. Sebastio, M. Amoretti, A. Lafuente, A. Scala

ACM Transactions on Modeling and Computer Simulation

LQ placeholder

From ecology to finance (and back?): a review on entropy-based null models for the analysis of bipartite networks

M. Straka, G. Caldarelli, T. Squartini, F. Saracco

Journal of Statistical Physics

LQ placeholder

How well do experience curves predict technological progress? A method for making distributional forecasts

F. Lafond, A. Bailey, J. Bakker, D. Rebois, R. Zadourian, P. McSharry, D. Farmer

Technological Forecasting and Social Change

LQ placeholder

A complex network approach for the estimation of the energy demand of electric mobility

M. Mureddu, A. Facchini, A. Scala, G. Caldarelli, A. Damiano

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

Exactly solvable random graph ensemble with extensively many short cycles

F. Lopez, P. Barucca, M. Fekom, A. Coolen

Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical

LQ placeholder

Searching for great strategies

T. Fink, P. Ghemawat, M. Reeves

Strategy Science

LQ placeholder

Serendipity and strategy in rapid innovation

T. Fink, M. Reeves, R. Palma, R. Farr

Nature Communications

LQ placeholder

Network models of financial systemic risk: a review

F. Caccioli, P. Barucca, T. Kobayashi

Journal of Computational Social Science

LQ placeholder

Dirac cones in two-dimensional borane

M. Martinez-Canales, T. Galeev, A. Boldyrev, C. Pickard

Physical Review B

LQ placeholder

Bayesian networks analysis of malocclusion data

M. Scutari, P. Auconi, G. Caldarelli, L. Franchi

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

Quantum generalisation of feedforward neural networks

K. Wan, O. Dahlsten, H. Kristjansson, R. Gardner, M. Kim

Nature Quantum Information

LQ placeholder

Grand canonical validation of the bipartite international trade network

M. Straka, G. Caldarelli, F. Saracco

Physical Review E

LQ placeholder

Organic molecule fluorescence as an experimental test-bed for quantum jumps in thermodynamics

C. Browne, T. Farrow, O. Dahlsten, V. Vedral

Proceedings of the Royal Society A

LQ placeholder

Debunking in a world of tribes

F. Zollo, A. Bessi, M. Vicario, G. Caldarelli, L. Shekhtman, S. Havlin, W. Quattrociocchi

PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Exactly solvable model of memristive circuits: Lyapunov functional and mean field theory

F. Caravelli, P. Barucca

Sub. to European Physical Journal B

LQ placeholder

Mean grain diameters from thin sections: matching the average to the problem

R. Farr, V. Honour, M. Holness

Mineralogical Magazine

LQ placeholder

The mise en scene of memristive networks: effective memory, dynamics and learning

F. Caravelli

International Journal of Parallel, Emergent and Distributed Systems

LQ placeholder

Entropic equality for worst-case work at any protocol speed

O. Dahlsten, M. Choi, D. Braun, A. Garner, N. Halpern, V. Vedral

New Journal of Physics

LQ placeholder

Harnessing the secret structure of innovation

M. Reeves, T. Fink, R. Palma, J. Harnoss

MIT Sloan Management Review

LQ placeholder

Pathways towards instability in financial networks

M. Bardoscia, S. Battiston, F. Caccioli, G. Caldarelli

Nature Communications

LQ placeholder

Disentangling group and link persistence in Dynamic Stochastic Block models

P. Barucca, F. Lillo, P. Mazzarisi, D. Tantari

Sub. to Journal of Statistical Physics

LQ placeholder

Optimal counter-current exchange networks

R. Farr, Y. Mao

Physical Review E

LQ placeholder

Distress propagation in complex networks: the case of non-linear DebtRank

M. Bardoscia, F. Caccioli, J. Perotti, G. Vivaldo, G. Caldarelli

PLoS ONE

LQ placeholder

Mitigating cascades in sandpile models: an immunization strategy for systemic risk?

A. Scala, V. Zlatić, G. Caldarelli, G. D’Agostino

Journal de Physique IV

LQ placeholder

Islanding the power grid on the transmission level: less connections for more security

M. Mureddu, G. Caldarelli, A. Damiano, A. Scala, H. Meyer-Ortmanns

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

Resolution of ranking hierarchies in directed networks

E. Letizia, P. Barucca, F. Lillo

Sub. to PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Optimal growth trajectories with finite carrying capacity

F. Caravelli, L. Sindoni, F. Caccioli, C. Ududec

Physical Review E

LQ placeholder

The price of complexity in financial networks

S. Battiston, G. Caldarelli, R. May, T. Roukny, J. Stiglitz

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

LQ placeholder

Tunnelling necessitates negative Wigner function

Y. Lin, O. Dahlsten

Sub. to Physical Review Letters

LQ placeholder

Network valuation in financial systems

P. Barucca, M. Bardoscia, F. Caccioli, M. D’Errico, G. Visentin, S. Battiston, G. Caldarelli

Sub. to Mathematical Finance

LQ placeholder

Cascades in interdependent flow networks

A. Scala, P. Lucentini, G. Caldarelli, G. D’Agostino

Physica D Nonlinear Phenomena

LQ placeholder

Bounds on transient instability for complex ecosystems

F. Caravelli, P. Staniczenko

PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Concurrent enhancement of percolation and synchronization in adaptive networks

Y. Eom, S. Boccaletti, G. Caldarelli

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

Networks of plants: how to measure similarity in vegetable species

G. Vivaldo, E. Masi, C. Pandolfi, S. Mancuso, G. Caldarelli

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

Emergence of strongly connected components in continuum disk-spin percolation

F. Caravelli, M. Bardoscia, F. Caccioli

Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment

LQ placeholder

Eigenvalues of neutral networks: Interpolating between hypercubes

T. Reeves, R. Farr, J. Blundell, A. Gallagher, T. Fink

Discrete Mathematics

LQ placeholder

Geometric phases and cyclic isotropic cosmologies

L. Banchi, F. Caravelli

Classical and Quantum Gravity

LQ placeholder

How predictable is technological progress?

D. Farmer, F. Lafond

Research Policy

LQ placeholder

Photonic Maxwell’s demon

M. Vidrighin, O. Dahlsten, M. Barbieri, M. Kim, V. Vedral, I. Walmsley

Physical Review Letters

LQ placeholder

Coupling news sentiment with web browsing data improves prediction of intra-day price dynamics

G. Ranco, I. Bordino, G. Bormetti, G. Caldarelli, F. Lillo, M. Treccani

PLoS ONE

LQ placeholder

Subcritical U-Bootstrap percolation models have non-trivial phase transitions

P. Balister, B. Bollobas, M. Przykucki, P. Smith

Transactions of the American Mathematical Society

LQ placeholder

Green power grids: how energy from renewable sources affects networks and markets

M. Mureddu, G. Caldarelli, A. Chessa, A. Scala, A. Damiano

PLoS ONE

LQ placeholder

Hyperbolicity measures democracy in real-world networks

M. Borassi, A. Chessa, G. Caldarelli

Physical Review E

LQ placeholder

Quantifying noise in mass spectrometry and yeast two-hybrid protein interaction detection experiments

A. Annibale, A. Coolen, N. Planell-Morell

Journal of the Royal Society Interface

LQ placeholder

The effects of Twitter sentiment on stock price returns

G. Ranco, D. Aleksovski, G. Caldarelli, M. Grčar, I. Mozetič

PLoS ONE

LQ placeholder

Twitter-based analysis of the dynamics of collective attention to political parties

Y. Eom, M. Puliga, J. Smailović, I. Mozetič, G. Caldarelli

PLoS ONE

LQ placeholder

A measure of majorization emerging from single-shot statistical mechanics

D. Egloff, O. Dahlsten, R. Renner, V. Vedral

New Journal of Physics

LQ placeholder

DebtRank: a microscopic foundation for shock propagation

M. Bardoscia, S. Battiston, F. Caccioli, G. Caldarelli

PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Self-organization of knowledge economies

F. Lafond

Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control

LQ placeholder

Scale-free networks as an epiphenomenon of memory

F. Caravelli, A. Hamma, M. Ventra

EPL

LQ placeholder

The heterogeneous dynamics of economic complexity

M. Cristelli, A. Tacchella, L. Pietronero

PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Maximum percolation time in two-dimensional bootstrap percolation

F. Benevides, M. Przykucki

SIAM Journal on Discrete Mathematics

LQ placeholder

Random graph ensembles with many short loops

E. Roberts, T. Coolen

ESAIM: Proceedings and surveys

LQ placeholder

How the taxonomy of products drives the economic development of countries

A. Zaccaria, M. Cristelli, A. Tacchella, L. Pietronero

PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Credit default swaps networks and systemic risk

M. Puliga, G. Caldarelli, S. Battiston

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

Easily repairable networks: reconnecting nodes after damage

R. Farr, J. Harer, T. Fink

Physical Review Letters

LQ placeholder

The size of patent categories: USPTO 1976-2006

F. Lafond

NU-MERIT Working Paper Series

LQ placeholder

Entanglement typicality

O. Dahlsten, C. Lupo, S. Mancini, A. Serafini

Journal of Physics A

LQ placeholder

The rise of China in the international trade network: a community core detection approach

Z. Zhu, F. Cerina, A. Chessa, G. Caldarelli, M. Riccaboni

PLoS ONE

LQ placeholder

Bootstrap percolation on Galton–Watson trees

B. Bollobas, K. Gunderson, C. Janson, M. Przykucki

Electronic Journal of Probability

LQ placeholder

Predicting interface structures: from SrTiO 3 to graphene

G. Schusteritsch, C. Pickard

Physical Review B

LQ placeholder

A multi-Level geographical study of Italian political elections from Twitter data

G. Caldarelli, A. Chessa, F. Pammolli, G. Pompa, M. , M. Riccaboni, G. Riotta

PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Memory effects in stock price dynamics: evidences of technical trading

F. Garzarelli, M. Cristelli, G. Pompa, A. Zaccaria, L. Pietronero

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

Electron-phonon coupling and the metalization of solid helium at terapascal pressures

B. Monserrat, N. Drummond, C. Pickard, R. Needs

Physical Review Letters

LQ placeholder

Self-healing networks: redundancy and structure

W. Quattrociocchi, G. Caldarelli, A. Scala

PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Imperfections in a two-dimensional hierarchical structure

D. Rayneau-Kirkhope, Y. Mao, R. Farr

Physical Review E

LQ placeholder

Default cascades in complex networks: topology and systemic risk

T. Roukny, H. Bersini, H. Pirotte, G. Caldarelli, S. Battiston

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

Immune networks: multitasking capabilities near saturation

E. Agliari, A. Annibale, A. Barra, A. Coolen, D. Tantari

Journal of Physics A

LQ placeholder

Economic complexity: conceptual grounding of a new metrics for global competitiveness

A. Tacchella, M. Cristelli, G. Caldarelli, A. Gabrielli, L. Pietronero

Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control

LQ placeholder

Measuring the intangibles: a metric for the economic complexity of countries and products

M. Cristelli, A. Gabrielli, A. Tacchella, G. Caldarelli, L. Pietronero

PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Low-temperature behaviour of social and economic networks

D. Garlaschelli, S. Ahnert, T. Fink, G. Caldarelli

Entropy

LQ placeholder

Optimal scales in weighted networks

D. Garlaschelli, S. Ahnert, T. Fink, G. Caldarelli

Social Informatics

LQ placeholder

Immune networks: multi-tasking capabilities at medium load

E. Agliari, A. Annibale, A. Barra, A. Coolen, D. Tantari

Journal of Physics A

LQ placeholder

Optimization of fractal space frames under gentle compressive load

D. Rayneau-Kirkhope, Y. Mao, R. Farr

Physical Review E

LQ placeholder

Towers of strength

D. Rayneau-Kirkhope, Y. Mao, R. Farr

Physics World

LQ placeholder

Evolution of controllability in interbank networks

D. Delpini, S. Battiston, M. Riccaboni, G. Gabbi, F. Pammolli, G. Caldarelli

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

Reconstructing a credit network

G. Caldarelli, A. Chessa, F. Pammolli, A. Gabrielli, M. Puliga

Nature Physics

LQ placeholder

Complex derivatives

S. Battiston, G. Caldarelli, C. Georg, R. May, J. Stiglitz

Nature Physics

LQ placeholder

Bootstrapping topology and systemic risk of complex network using the fitness model

N. Musmeci, S. Battiston, G. Caldarelli, M. Puliga, A. Gabrielli

Journal of Statistical Physics

LQ placeholder

Weighted networks as randomly reinforced urn processes

G. Caldarelli, A. Chessa, I. Crimaldi, F. Pammolli

Physical Review E

LQ placeholder

Ultralight fractal structures from hollow tubes

D. Rayneau-Kirkhope, Y. Mao, R. Farr

Physical Review Letters

LQ placeholder

Hierarchical space frames for high mechanical efficiency: Fabrication and mechanical testing

D. Rayneau-Kirkhope, Y. Mao, R. Farr, J. Segal

Mechanics Research Communications

LQ placeholder

A new metric for countries’ fitness and products’ complexity

A. Tacchella, M. Cristelli, G. Caldarelli, A. Gabrielli, L. Pietronero

Scientific Reports

LQ placeholder

A network analysis of countries’ export flows: firm grounds for the building blocks of the economy

G. Caldarelli, M. Cristelli, A. Gabrielli, L. Pietronero, A. Scala, A. Tacchella

PLOS ONE

LQ placeholder

Using networks to understand medical data: the case of class III malocclusions

A. Scala, P. Auconi, M. Scazzocchio, G. Caldarelli, J. McNamara, L. Franchi

PLoS ONE

LQ placeholder

Web search queries can predict stock market volumes

I. Bordino, S. Battiston, G. Caldarelli, M. Cristelli, A. Ukkonen, I. Weber

PLoS ONE

LQ placeholder

Networks with arbitrary edge multiplicities

V. Zlatić, D. Garlaschelli, G. Caldarelli

EPL

LQ placeholder

When are cellular automata random?

J. Coe, S. Ahnert, T. Fink

EPL

LQ placeholder

Shear elastic deformation and particle packing in plant cell dispersions

P. Lopez-Sanchez, V. Chapara, S. Schumm, R. Farr

Food Biophysics

LQ placeholder

Diffusional Monte Carlo model of liquid-phase sintering

A. R.S.Farr

Mathematics and Computers in Simulation

LQ placeholder

Self-assembly, modularity, and physical complexity

S. Ahnert, I. Johnston, T. Fink, J. Doye, A. Louis

Physical Review E

LQ placeholder

Tie knots, random walks and topology

T. Fink, Y. Mao

Physica A

LQ placeholder

Single elimination competition

T. Fink, J. Coe, S. Ahnert

EPL

122 / 122 papers